Theresa Muñoz: I Would Like Scotland To Be In Control Of Its Own Immigration System


Before I go into why I’m voting Yes in September (my first vote ever), I’ll say a bit about my background and how it relates to my decision. My father comes from Mindanao in the Philippines and his father was from Madrid. My mother is from Manila. I was born and raised in Vancouver, Canada, and now live permanently in Scotland. I suppose that makes this the Spanish-Filipino-Scottish-Canadian take on the independence referendum, which I suspect is a fairly unusual one.

My parents could have met in the Philippines because my mother, as we discovered later, was the nurse to my father’s cousin. Instead they met in the stationary aisle in Simpson’s Department Store, Toronto having come separately to Canada. My mother and I were both twenty two years old when we moved countries. I’m glad I share an immigrant narrative with my family – they know how hard it is to reinvent your life in a new place.

I came to Scotland in 2006 to do a Masters in Creative Writing at Glasgow University, with poet Tom Leonard as my tutor. I had never been to Glasgow before. In fact, I had never been on an international flight before. My mom sewed seven hundred quid in cash into a secret pocket inside my jeans…I think she thought I was going to get mugged as soon as I landed. I loved my Masters at Glasgow and got a Fresh Talent visa for two years so that I could stay. I worked at the Centre for Contemporary Arts and freelanced for The Herald and The List. I then got a student visa and a scholarship to do a PhD in Scottish Literature on the work of Tom Leonard. In the meantime I published a poetry pamphlet called Close and moved to Edinburgh where I work as a researcher and tutor. I made my way through the ranks of visas and I finally got my Permanent Resident card.

Last year, I took the Life in the UK test which was an interesting experience. I had to learn 30,000 facts from the test’s preparatory book. I know the names of all of Henry the Eighth’s wives, and who opened the first curry house in Britain. Because I see myself as a Scot now, I was interested in the Scottish content in the test. My test had very few questions about Scotland. The ones I remember were: where did Bonnie Prince Charlie raise his army, and what is the maximum level of debt that can be handled in the Small Claims court in Scotland. Otherwise, Scotland sometimes was seen to be treated as comic relief. One online practice question, for instance, asked me to name the constituent parts of the UK Government: House of Lords, House of Commons or House of Fraser.

It’s not been easy to stay here in Scotland and it’s getting harder. In Canada if you are not an immigrant yourself then somebody in the extended family almost certainly is. Here the immigration system seems a mystery to many as they don’t know anybody who has gone through it. I get very upset when I read news stories of people like me who are turned down for visas, or Yashika Bageerathi, the teenager originally from Mauritius who was recently deported before finishing her A-levels. Immigration is still seen as a good thing in Canada. By contrast, I think Britain is close to treating every immigrant as an imposition, if it hasn’t reached that point already.

One of the reasons I’m voting Yes is that I would like Scotland to be in control of its own immigration system, which I don’t believe currently fits either Scotland’s needs or Scotland’s inclinations. I come from a very multicultural country. Canada’s commitment to multiculturalism is the reason my parents are there and I think that Scotland aspires to be multicultural as well. The avenue to residency that I initially took – as an international student who got a Fresh Talent visa – no longer exists. I don’t think it’s fair that it is now very difficult for Scots living outside of Scotland with non-EU partners to come back to Scotland. I don’t think it is right that so many good people have to leave when they want to stay here and contribute. I think Scotland would do things differently if it could and that that can only happen with independence.

It also frustrates me that Scotland can’t make independent decisions on the other things that matter most – the war in Iraq, for instance, which Canada refused to participate in, or nuclear weapons on its territory, which Canada got rid of. I sense how different Scotland is from Westminster already and as a young, global citizen committed to living and working in Scotland, I don’t feel represented by the UK government’s increasingly inward-looking, predominantly male, predominantly white, culture.

I think sometimes about the former Prime Minister of Canada Pierre Trudeau and his revamping of the immigration system which created the multicultural Canada that you can see today just by walking down the street. I think too of the Constitution Act which he signed thirty-two years ago, and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms which was embedded in it. Scotland could do these things if it chooses to – not simply by copying them but in its own inimitable way.

I hesitate to finish with two slogans from North American advertising culture, but, for once, ‘just do it’ and ‘be all that you can be’ seem to fit the bill quite nicely.

Theresa Muñoz
National Collective

Theresa Muñoz is a poet and critic born in Vancouver, Canada, now living in Edinburgh. She was an Overseas Research Scholar at the University of Glasgow where she wrote the first thesis on the poet Tom Leonard. She works as a tutor/researcher and is also the online editor for the Scottish Review of Books. Her pamphlet Close was published by HappenStance Press in 2012.

National Collective are currently raising funds for this summers’ Yestival tour of Scotland. Please donate what you can at:


There are 6 comments

  1. Steve Ward

    As a Scot living in Canada I’ve seen all these points the opposite way. Canada and the USA have a similar relationship to Scotland and England yet Washington D.C don’t make direct decisions on Canada’s behalf.

  2. Elliott Steven

    Wel said – Scotland needs immigrants for all the reasons stated but it is alarming to hear that if you marry a non-EU person then you are largely rejected by the BritNat establishment. I would add that I doubt many people would know the answers to the Scottish questions you were asked, never mind the English questions. Grand you’re here and by heck Scotland could use an injection of multi-culturism and I think they’d like it.

  3. Tern

    I want all the things you say, and I want to vote Yes and get them, and I wanted the Yes cause’s pro-immigration tone to be true.

    So how tragic is this? There is a spiteful enough closed little community anti-outsider streak in Scot nationalism, which I have encountered even from a top Yes-supporting cultural celebrity when arguing about this, that the Yes side is digging in behind a policy that will shut more of the diaspora out of Scotland and be a new Clearances: it will do this if the common travel areas break down, so they hide behind claiming they never will break down. It’s that they will not say, they seem determined not to say, that applications to register for citizenship by descent from a parent or grandparent, giving evidence of that descent, will be accepted by entitlement and can’t be selectively refused.

    That they won’t say that, is forcing me to vote No and not get all the good things you have written of, because of the magnitude of cruelty and dividing families it would be to take away certainty of residence from anyone of Scottish family background who has it now. The longer they go on not saying it, the more No votes I may cause who won’t change to Yes like I will if they eventually say it.

  4. Liam Alastair Crouse

    DItto from me; I was at uni from 2008-12, studying Gaelic and archaeology. 2012 was the year of the visa restricting and the post=uni visa which had been on offer since our start was taken away. Whereas I could have easily obtained a job (in Gaelic) in Scotland, I was left unemployed in America.

  5. God Save The Queen

    YES SCOTLAND is Great for Britain. YES Scotland will amplify our
    collective voice in international institutions and ensure an end to
    the madness of nuclear weapons. Scotland and England and
    Wales and Ireland will all be equal Commonwealth Partners.
    VOTE YES. BE FREE in the new UK=OK! and no2eu .com.

Post Your Thoughts